BBE Epidemic - Every problem (should) have a solution.
Summary: howe1850 shared their concerns about the BBE (Bad Buyer Experience) metrics on eBay, highlighting issues with transparency and customer service. They expressed frustration over the perceived automated system flaws, specifically regarding the lack of distinction between unjustly affected international sellers and those rightfully banned. They also criticized eBay's customer service, suggesting it lacks the personalized support it once had. In response, furisa@ebay from eBay clarified the evaluation process for BBE metrics and acknowledged the feedback, promising to share it with relevant teams. howe1850 further questioned a discrepancy in their seller performance metrics, seeking more clarity.
Another thread on the topic, but I feel it's important to keep bringing this issue up from every angle and the impact it's having.
I posted my story (it's a couple of pages long, but someone was kind enough to post a summary in the comments if you scroll down a bit) on the regular boards - https://community.ebay.com/forum/selling-57920/topic/bbe-automated-metrics-and-the-lack-of-customer-service-162018/
Anyways, it is immensely clear that the BBE system is flawed on a detrimental level. The lack of transparency, proper information in regards to "Service standard policy - bad buyer experience rate" is lackluster at best, as well incorrect information provided, and information withheld. I have noticed a massive growth in similar cases in the past few months on different platforms where, international sellers are being unjustly having their selling privileges restricted. Of course there are many sellers that are deservedly banned from selling, but it is vividly clear that the AI automated metrics is not able to differentiate at any level. That is a problem.
Which brings us to another problem, that is customer service. I have through various channels tried to reach what has been said to be the "Hong Kong Department" that supposedly is in charge of the BBE program, as well other specialized teams, or ANY department that isn't the main one in Bangalore that does nothing, but use automated forms. All roads have lead to Bangalore, thus the only logical conclusion I can reach, is that there is no "Hong Kong Department", or specialized teams for BBE. As I've rarely had the need to contact customer service, my picture of it had remained from what it was about 5-10 years ago. Excellent, personal (i.e. human) service with clear dialogue and answers to my inquiries. Well, I can safely say that you can't find a single person that feels that way about the customer service today, and that fact alone is truly a sad, sad outcome.
On another note, my service metrics jumped to the three month cycle last month, and my current rate: Jun 2025 - May 2026
Item not as described
Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop 0/216 = 0.00% (Peers average is 0.05% - I find this number shockingly low, that's 1 out of 2000 transactions on average)
Collectibles 0/1483 = 0.00% (You and your peers average is 0.00% - Okay...There's definitely something funny going on here)
Item not received
International: Matured Region 16/1658 = 0.97% (Peers average is 0.24% - I do find this number low as well, but no as extreme as the INAD's)
International: Emerging Region 0/41 = 0.00% (No peer benchmarks)
As to why "Seller Unfulfilled" is not visible to view, I do not know (which was my issue, if you read my original post, many of whom deemed to be a novel). I do find these numbers troublesome in the sense that the automated metrics have been turned up to 11 and sellers will keep dropping like flies in order for these averages to stay that low. No business or person is infallible to that degree, and these numbers are unrealistic in my opinion. If you disagree, I would love to hear your point of view.
I have a tendency to ramble, and I could probably make this the second novel of a series, but my main point of this would be;
Instead of customer service saying nothing can be done, how about forwarding the complaints, from YOUR sellers, that this is impacting instead of throwing them under the bus and not assisting them in any way. This growing BBE epidemic, which will keep growing until someone far enough up on the food chain is actually provided with this information and looks into the matter. Time for eBay to get proactive in solving the issue instead of waiting until enough harm has been caused for them to react. Every problem has a solution, even this one. While I do believe it will be corrected eventually, it might be years or decades before eBay does the right thing. Heck, we might be exploring Uranus by that time.
Would be great to have respectful discussion, be it if you agree or disagree, or if you've tried or been able to (seems impossible, to say the least) reach anyone inside eBay on a higher level to bring this matter to light. Gamestop might be a few more years away still. JOKING.
howe1850
furisa@ebay
Hello @howe1850
Greetings from team eBay!
Thanks for taking the time to share your experience. We understand how frustrating it can be when you're trying to make sense of your performance metrics, especially after reaching out through different support channels for clarification. We genuinely appreciate you sharing your feedback, as it helps us understand the concerns sellers are experiencing.
We'd like to provide some clarification on how the BBE metrics work. A Bad Buyer Experience (BBE) is generally recorded when a transaction results in an Item Not Received (INR) case or when an order is cancelled. These metrics are designed to help us monitor the overall buying experience on the platform and encourage successful order fulfillment.
While shipping orders on time and uploading valid tracking information are important, it's equally important that buyers receive their items within the expected delivery timeframe. This helps create a positive buying experience and reduces the likelihood of issues such as INR claims, which can impact seller performance.
Regarding the Service Level and Service Metrics, the evaluation period is based on transaction volume. If an account has at least 400 transactions within the last three months, the system evaluates performance using that three-month period. If there are fewer than 400 transactions, the evaluation is extended to the previous 12 months to ensure there is sufficient transaction data for a fair assessment.
For the Seller Unfulfilled metric, this generally refers to transactions that were cancelled by the seller. You can also view these transactions in your Seller Level Report, where more detailed information is available.
You can find additional information about seller performance and these metrics here:
https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/selling/seller-performance-overview?id=4080
We also appreciate your comments about your customer service experience. We understand how important it is to receive clear, consistent guidance when you have questions about your account. Your feedback has been noted and will be shared with the appropriate teams as part of our ongoing efforts to improve the support experience for our sellers.
Thank you again for taking the time to raise these concerns. We value your feedback and remain committed to making our policies, metrics, and support experience as clear and helpful as possible.
Regards,
eBay Team
howe1850
OPCould you please explain why my "Transactions you canceled for being out of stock" is at 0.00%, when BBE metrics put 43 transactions (from two orders to the same US buyer, after the buyer was refunded in full after stating they had not received the orders - with no cases even opened) as seller unfulfilled. Why aren't they visible in seller level? If they are separate entities, then why? There is no logic whatsoever.